The usa patriot act threatens our civil liberties by sala nolan april 2003 on oct. A reference handbook is an indepth examination of the difficult wartime task of balancing civil liberties against national security. Impact on freedoms and civil liberties by sunya kashan english 1102 espite being the superpower of the world, the united states of america does not enjoy any exception from the global threats and challenges. Welcome,you are looking at books for reading, the usa patriot act, you will able to read or download in pdf or epub books and notice some of author may have lock the live reading for some of country. Us congress, 1022001 one day later, senate majority leader and future anthrax target tom daschle dsd says he doubts the senate will take up this bill in the one week timetable the administration wants. Just weeks later, october 26, 2006, president george w. The usa patriot act and civil liberties part ii i n the united states, there is an inherent tension between the presidents obligation to defend the constitution, particularly the bill of rights, and the fundamental freedoms conveyed to u. These gag order provisions have been held unconstitutional in several legal cases. The patriot acts stated purpose is to deter and punish terrorist acts in the united states and around the world, to enhance law enforcement investigatory. On october 30, 2001, however, npr did broadcast a show where a justice department official described provisions of the patriot act and a civil liberties advocate explained his concerns. The patriot act prohibits americans who receive nsls from telling anyone. I dont think theres a playbook for this, says caleb kruckenberg, litigation counsel for the new civil liberties alliance in washington, d.
Patriot act infringes on civil liberties, allows for privacy invasion. Civil liberties groups say the provision could sweep in protesters and those suspected of involvement. The civil liberties organization contended the patriot act had blurred the line between investigations of actual terrorists and those not suspected of doing anything wrong. The house voted 356 to 66, and the senate, 90 to 1, to support the usa. Congress is holding hearings on the act and considering, among other issues. This guide takes an indepth look at whats in the act, its destruction of civil liberties, and the dangers of hasty legislation with no regard to the constitution.
Patriot act are set to expire or, in legal parlance, sunset. The usa patriot act threatens our civil liberties united. Civil liberties study guide by spartandan95 includes 51 questions covering vocabulary, terms and more. Patriot act infringes on civil liberties, allows for. Apr 20, 2005 on december 31, sixteen portions of the u. By undermining the role of the courts, congress and the press in providing. The patriot act has been the cause of significant controversy since its passage. Or, rather, is it a blatant violation of the united states constitution and americans civil liberties. The patriot act and civil liberties jurist archives. End mass surveillance under the patriot act just 45 days after the attacks of september 11, 2001, a panicked congress passed, with virtually no debate, the usa patriot act. The usa patriot act a civil liberties briefing on october 26, 2001 the us congress passed, and president bush signed into law, the usa patriot act, an acronym for uniting and strengthening america by providing appropriate tools required to intercept and obstruct terrorism. A justice department ruling on october 31st permitting the government to monitor communications between federal detainees and their lawyers if this is seen as reasonably necessary to deter acts of terrorism.
Automatic zoom actual size page fit page width 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 200% 300% 400% more information. Congress passed the usa patriot act to enhance the. The usa patriot act american civil liberties union. Terrorizing middleeasterners, retraction of civil liberties, and the usa patriot act jennifer y. In debate over patriot act, lawmakers weigh risks vs.
The ibrief concludes that both sections infringe upon citizens civil liberties to a degree incommensurate with their value for fighting terrorism. The special operations branch receives civil rights and civil liberties complaints via mail, email, telephone, and facsimile. Sep 11, 2003 the controversial patriot act, which critics decry as an erosion of u. Jul 21, 2003 the inspector general said that from dec. I am more concerned about security than civil liberties. Panelists included steven brill, a newsweek columnist who recently published after. For example, according to the national league of cities, by mid2005 more than 2,000 communities had passed resolutions expressing concern with civil liberties issues in the patriot act. Under the auspices of combating terror, the bush administration took many steps following 911 that according to some have curtailed civil rights.
A closer look open pdf 75 kb this paper examines the provisions of the patriot act which were designed to increase information sharing between intelligence and law enforcement agencies, underscores the implications of their broader investigative scope with respect to our nations civil liberties, and provides recommendations to improve future versions of. End mass surveillance under the patriot act american. Library associations urge congress to increase oversight. The patriot act and civil liberties america magazine. In addition, two investigative specialists support the unit and divide their time between patriot act and fbidea responsibilities. Section 2 of the patriot act, titled, authority for delaying notice of the execution of a warrant, allows governmental officials to search private property without prior notice to the owner of the property. This reflects the american emphasis on civil and political rights, rather than the compendium of rights recognized by international human rights doctrines.
The patriot act protects our security and does not infringe on our civil liberties, nahmias countered. Set to expire december 31, 2005, fourteen of the sixteen provisions from the original act were resigned permanently. The patriot act is a blatant violation of constitution and civil liberties sadeghi, 2003by enacting the patriot act the white house willingly sacrificed citizens rights such as due process in the name of. The patriot act vs civil liberties 1016 words 123 help me. The patriot act s stated purpose is to deter and punish terrorist acts in the united states and around the world, to enhance law enforcement investigatory. The american civil liberties union wednesday filed the first lawsuit against the patriot act, the antiterrorism law passed after the attacks of september 11, 2001. Charlene thomascivil libertiesthe limitless power granted to the patriot act allows it to freely and continuously impede on the rights of american citizens. Civil rights and civil liberties are granted to the people as per the constitution. The patriot act can be used to catch wanted criminals. Next, the civil liberties implications of that provision are considered, along with any abuses that have occurred to date. This 342page usa patriot act was passed on october 26, 2001. While not part of the patriot act, this provision also sunsets on dec.
The civil liberties organization contended the patriot act had blurred the line between investigations of actual terrorists and those not suspected of. The usa patriot act and government actions that threaten our civil liberties. The usa patriot act a civil liberties briefing aclu of. Quizlet flashcards, activities and games help you improve your grades. Founded in 1920, the american civil liberties union aclu is one of the oldest interest groups in the united states.
I would like to contend that this war is not only a cancer to our economy but even more disastrous, a cancer to our civil liberties and freedoms as american citizens. Much of the literature contained in this bibliography examines the repercussions of the usa patriot act through the analysis of civil liberties. The patriot act s impact on civil liberties miami criminal lawyer. Surveillance under the usapatriot act american civil. Essay the usa patriot act and civil liberties 1260 words. The patriot act has raised many concerns about whether it infringes on the civil liberties of the people of this nation. Report on the telephone records program conducted under. Civil liberties groups complained that the patriot act, hastily passed in a national atmosphere of grief, anger, and fear, granted the federal government too much power over innocent people or to track private records. Surveillance under the patriot act american civil liberties. Most of its provisions are not controversial, and it provides us with updated tools to combat new technologies available to terrorists. Patriot act infringes on civil liberties, allows for privacy. The usa patriot act of 2001 goes far beyond the antiterrorism act of 1996, enacted in the wake of the 1995 oklahoma bombing, which legal critics at that time termed one of the worst assaults on the constitution in decades. Difference between civil rights and civil liberties.
End mass surveillance under the patriot act american civil. The patriot act is one response allowing the united states to wage war against an enemy that attacked the country in disguise, while remaining true to the countrys founding ethics of freedom, equality, privacy, and human dignity. Civil liberties conflicts between the fraternal order of police and the aclu are most likely to be examples of. The usa patriot act and civil liberties september 11, 2001 sparked many different feelings into the hearts of americans. Jun 17, 2011 the american civil liberties union aclu argued court approvals for business record access jumped from 21 in 2009 to 96 in 2010.
If it available for your country it will shown as book reader and user fully subscribe will benefit by having full. Essay on patriot act violates civil liberties 1838 words. The patriot act is a more than 300page document passed by the u. Among its earliest and most vocal critics has been the american civil liberties union aclu, which has brought several lawsuits challenging the constitutionality of the legislation. Act and government actions that threaten our civil liberties with great haste and secrecy and in the name of the war on terrorism, congress passed legislation that gives the executive branch sweeping new powers that undermine the bill of rights and are unnecessary to keep us safe. Patriot act civil liberties and civil rights in the. The usa patriot act is a textbook example of how the united states federal government expands its power. This essay offers an examination of the legal provision of the usa patriot act.
The law amounted to an overnight revision of the nations surveillance laws that vastly expanded the governments authority to spy on its own citizens, while simultaneously reducing checks and balances on those powers. Chip pitts talked about his concerns with the usa patriot providing appropriate tools required to intercept and obstruct terrorism act of 2001 and civil liberties. The government might infringe on some peoples rights. Those who were gravely affected were mostly muslims or people from middle eastern descents. Just six weeks after the september 11 attacks, a panicked congress passed the usa patriot act, an overnight revision of the nations surveillance laws that vastly expanded the governments authority to spy on its own citizens, while simultaneously reducing checks and balances on those powers like judicial oversight, public accountability, and the ability to.
Bush signed the usa patriot act causing controversial debates based on the effects the act plays on american civil liberties. Between 2003 and 2005, the fbi made 53 reported criminal referrals to prosecutors as a result of 143,074 nsls. Is the patriot act an invaluable tool in our fight against terrorism, as the bush administration would have us believe. As patriot act provisions expired in mid2015 and the freedom act redefined the national security agencys role in phone data collection, the constitutional issues of the fourth amendment continue to be carefully examined. These civil liberties are what our members of the armed forces fight to protect. The book focuses on the aspects that have made the patriot act pa a topic of great concern, especially since the patriot act has lost much of its power due to judicial intervention.
This paper examines the provisions of the patriot act which were designed to increase information sharing between intelligence and law enforcement agencies underscores the implications of their broader investigative scope with respect to our nations civil liberties and provides recommendations to improve future versions of this legislation. Civil rights are those that are granted by a government for the protection of its citizens in respect to guaranteeing fairness and checking discrimination. Within weeks of the september 11 terrorist attacks, overwhelming majorities in both houses of congress passed the usa patriot act. Interest group politics the sedition act of 1798 was, in part, the result of strained relations between the us and. The patriot act continues to infringe on civil liberties. Patriot act and civil liberties public safety or freedom.
People sprang into action to seek revenge and protect americas precious soils from another deadly attack by reinforcing americas strength through her government. Aug 01, 2005 the patriot act and civil liberties the editors august 01, 2005 president bush wants the entire act to be made permanent, contending that it has made the united states safer in the wake of the. To illustrate this, one need only take a look at the patriot act, passed barely a month after the 911 terrorist attacks. Letter from civil liberties groups to house judiciary. National security and civil liberties in post911 era by carroll doherty the revelations that obama administration secretly collected phone records and accessed the internet activity of millions of americans have raised new questions about the publics willingness to sacrifice civil liberties in the interests of national security. Under the second program, the government collects the content of electronic communications, including phone calls and emails, where the targets are reasonably believed to be nonu. The patriot act and its infringment on civil liberties. Numerous communities in the us have expressed condemnation with the patriot act since it has only helped with the violation of the civil liberties of people.
Introduction when terrorists struck the united states on september 11, 2001, killing thousands of. Chief among these was the passage of the usa patriot act of 2001, which was signed by. After students have selected one of the acts and decided whether the passage of the act was justified or in violation of the civil liberties of people, they will write an argumentative essay in which they will argue against or defend the act. Essay on patriot act violates civil liberties 1838 words 8 pages since the terrorist suicide bombed the world trade center and a wing of the pentagon, there has been a change in the relationship between the united states government and the people. Hastily passed 45 days after 911 in the name of national security, the patriot act was the first of many changes to surveillance laws that made it easier for the government to spy on ordinary americans by expanding the authority to monitor phone and email communications, collect bank and credit reporting records, and track the activity of innocent americans on the internet. The antiterrorism patriot act is introduced in congress on october 2, 2001 see october 2, 2001, but it is not well received by all. On the other hand, the lack of a patriot act is a threat to national security.
List of books and articles about usa patriot act online. Jun 02, 2015 washington just one senator voted against the patriot act, calling it a violation of civil liberties when it passed in the frightening, angry days after the attacks of sept. The usa patriot act and its effects on national security, immigrant rights, and civil liberties in general were the focus of a forum at osis new york office on june 11, 2003. The patriot act has, in conjunction with other legislation, strengthened civil liberties. Civil liberties groups urge the house judiciary committee in hold hearings into the intelligence communitys use of a domestic surveillance power known as section 215 of the patriot act. Therefore it need a free signup process to obtain the book. The usa patriot act has become a channel for the violation of a persons basic civil liberties. The american civil liberties union aclu argued court approvals for business record access jumped from 21 in 2009 to 96 in 2010. The patriot act protects the people from danger but jeopardizes their civil rights. Provisions of the usa patriot act that raise concerns for civil liberties include.
Since the usa patriot act was passed, civil liberties have been under attack through the following executive actions. The usa patriot act patriot act was established after september 11, 2001 911 when terrorists attacked the united states. With great haste and secrecy and in the name of the war on terrorism, congress passed legislation that gives the executive branch sweeping new powers that undermine the bill of rights and are unnecessary to keep us safe. The patriot act s broader investigative scope invades our nations civil liberties and once again unsettles the delicate balance between our nations strategy on domestic security and the civil. It gave the military and other law enforcers the power to act beyond their means.
Freedom is the right to privacy, free speech, to vote, to a fair judicial system, and the right to be free from unreasonable searches. Jun 11, 2003 the usa patriot act and its effects on national security, immigrant rights, and civil liberties in general were the focus of a forum at osis new york office on june 11, 2003. According to rand beers, the act made the public less secure. Patriot act 2 is fundamentally flawed because it relies on a false premise that america can be safer if we do away with basic checks and balances.
The life or death of the act depends upon the behavior of terrorists. It would create a new opportunity for civil liberties defenders to lobby the secretive foreign intelligence surveillance court, and force the government to. The mission of this nonpartisan, notforprofit organization is to defend and preserve the individual rights and liberties guaranteed to every person in this country by the constitution and laws of the united states. The usa patriot acts effect on civil liberties open. The usa patriot act and government actions that threaten our civil liberties new legislation and government take away our freedom with great haste and secrecy and in the name of the war on terrorism, congress passed legislation that gives the executive branch sweeping new powers that undermine the bill of rights. The patriot act will prevent terrorist attacks on the united states. The usa patriot act sunset extension act of 2009 sunset extension act and the justice act of 2009 justice act reauthorize the sunsetting provisions of the usa patriot act with critical new protections for civil liberties and due process, including implementation of reasonable safeguards for national security letters, revised.
With 91 percent of registered voters unaware of the act s encroachment on civil liberties, the entire dispute might appear. The law amounted to an overnight revision of the nations surveillance laws that vastly expanded the governments authority to spy on its own citizens, while simultaneously. The patriot acts impact on civil liberties miami criminal. The usa patriot act additional reauthorizing amendments act of 2006 8pp. Information resources the usa patriot act and civil liberties.
1047 1367 1426 1472 588 1401 1308 791 415 1168 638 38 978 18 1107 1203 288 1106 1248 1175 820 1196 1117 1377 686 1421 507 1250 563 761 1229 985 795 917 94 739 1270 477 1333 1104 1421 587 1241 1124 955 649 1047